Letter to the editor |
Choice of ART programme for serodiscordant couples with an HIV infected male partner
1 CECOS Midi-Pyrénées, Research Group on Human Fertility (EA 3694), University Hospital Paule de Viguier and 2 Department of Virology, University Hospital Purpan, Toulouse, France
3 To whom correspondence should be addressed at: CECOS Midi-Pyrénées, Research Group on Human Fertility (EA 3694), University Hospital Paule de Viguier, TSA 70034, 31059 Toulouse Cedex 9, France. E-mail: bujan.l{at}chu-toulouse.fr
Sir,
Mencaglia et al. (2005)
report in a recent issue of Human Reproduction the results of an ICSI programme in serodiscordant couples where the male partner is infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and/or hepatitis C virus. In their conclusions, they affirm that ICSI is the method of choice to reduce the risk of viral transmission to the partner, whatever the fertility status of the couple.
The debate on HIV presence on spermatozoa is probably not definitively closed. However, while the presence of galactosyl-alkyl-acylglycerol (Brogi et al., 1995), a molecule structurally related to galactosylceramide which is an alternative receptor for HIV, has been reported on sperm membranes, this receptor requires an HIV co-receptor in order to penetrate and infect the cell. There have been several publications on the lack of HIV receptor expression on spermatozoa (Kim et al., 1999) and on the absence of HIV particles or genomes in spermatozoa fractions obtained after two techniques of sperm washing (Quayle et al., 1998; Kim et al., 1999; Pasquier et al., 2000; Bujan et al., 2002, 2004a). Although two studies have shown the presence of HIV nucleic acid after sperm preparation (Marina et al., 1998; Meseguer et al., 2002), we have demonstrated that the use of two successive preparation methods (i.e. sperm density gradient and swim-up methods) effectively yielded spermatozoa fractions with systematically undetectable HIV DNA and RNA (Pasquier et al., 2000; Bujan et al., 2004a) in more than 800 semen preparations to date, whatever the seminal viral load (Bujan et al., 2002). Moreover, although this was not mentioned by Mencaglia et al., several publications on intrauterine insemination (IUI) programmes in serodiscordant couples with an HIV-infected male partner have reported no case of female contamination (Semprini et al., 1992; Marina et al., 1998; Semprini et al., 1998; Gilling-Smith, 2000; Ohl et al., 2003; Bujan et al., 2004b). There is no clear evidence that ICSI is safer than IUI where HIV transmission risk is concerned. Furthermore, we have reported the results of 213 IUI cycles in such couples. The pregnancy rate per couple was 66%, and the percentage of couples with a child was 50% (Bujan et al., 2004b). These rates are comparable to the results of ICSI reported by Mencaglia et al.
In our opinion, there is no justification for systematic use of ICSI methods in these couples who are naturally fertile. In serodiscordant couples with HIV-positive men, compulsory condom use in order to avoid female contamination induces artificial sterility. The physician is then asked to help these couples to have a child, without contamination of the partner. Insemination, using spermatozoa prepared with both successive methods, is a very efficient assisted reproduction technique (ART) to help these fertile patients. ICSI does not increase the pregnancy rate per couple in fertile couples, and in addition, it exposes them to the side effects of this method: physical (treatment, ovarian puncture, anaesthesia, etc.) and emotional stress. Moreover, the cost of ICSI should be taken into account, particularly in countries with an inadequate health care insurance system. This point is particularly important because when a couple has no access to an ART programme, they may try to conceive naturally with exposure to HIV-transmission risk (Mandelbrot et al., 1997). We believe, in the light of present scientific knowledge, that patients should be informed about all available possibilities of reducing the risk of HIV transmission and that the choice of ART method should be related only to the fertility status of both partners.
References
Brogi A, Presentini R, Piomboni P, Collodel G, Strazza M, Solazzo D and Costantino-Ceccarini E (1995) Human sperm and spermatogonia express a galactoglycerolipid which interacts with gp120. J Submicrosc Cytol Pathol 27,565–571.[ISI][Medline]
Bujan L, Daudin M, Alvarez M, Massip P, Puel J and Pasquier C (2002) Intermittent human immunodeficiency type 1 virus (HIV-1) shedding in semen and efficiency of sperm processing despite high seminal HIV-1 RNA levels. Fertil Steril 78,1321–1323.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Bujan L, Daudin M, Matsuda T, Righi L, Thauvin L, Berges L, Izopet J, Berrebi A, Massip P and Pasquier C (2004a) Factors of intermittent HIV-1 excretion in semen and efficiency of sperm processing in obtaining spermatozoa without HIV-1 genomes. AIDS 18,757–766.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Bujan L, Pasquier C, Labeyrie E, Lanusse-Crousse P, Morucci M and Daudin M (2004b) Insemination with isolated and virologically tested spermatozoa is a safe way for human immunodeficiency type 1 virus-serodiscordant couples with an infected male partner to have a child. Fertil Steril 82,857–862.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Gilling-Smith C (2000) HIV prevention. Assisted reproduction in HIV-discordant couples. AIDS Read 10,581–587.[Medline]
Kim LU, Johnson MR, Barton S, Nelson MR, Sontag G, Smith JR, Gotch FM and Gilmour JW (1999) Evaluation of sperm washing as a potential method of reducing HIV transmission in HIV-discordant couples wishing to have children. AIDS 13,645–651.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Mandelbrot L, Heard I, Henrion-Geant E and Henrion R (1997) Natural conception in HIV-negative women with HIV-infected partners. Lancet 349,850–851.[ISI][Medline]
Marina S, Marina F, Alcolea R, Exposito R, Huguet J, Nadal J and Verges A (1998) Human immunodeficiency virus type 1-serodiscordant couples can bear healthy children after undergoing intrauterine insemination. Fertil Steril 70,35–39.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Mencaglia L, Falcone P, Lentini GM, Consigli S, Pisoni M, Lofiego V, Guidetti R, Piomboni P and De Leo V (2005) ICSI for treatment of human immunodeficiency virus and hepatitis C virus-serodiscordant couples with infected male partner. Hum Reprod 20,2242–2246.
Meseguer M, Garrido N, Gimeno C, Remohi J, Simon C and Pellicer A (2002) Comparison of polymerase chain reaction-dependent methods for determining the presence of human immunodeficiency virus and hepatitis C virus in washed sperm. Fertil Steril 78,1199–1202.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Ohl J, Partisani M, Wittemer C, Schmitt MP, Cranz C, Stoll-Keller F, Rongieres C, Bettahar-Lebugle K, Lang JM and Nisand I (2003) Assisted reproduction techniques for HIV serodiscordant couples: 18 months of experience. Hum Reprod 18,1244–1249.
Pasquier C, Daudin M, Righi L, Berges L, Thauvin L, Berrebi A, Massip P, Puel J, Bujan L and Izopet J (2000) Sperm washing and virus nucleic acid detection to reduce HIV and hepatitis C virus transmission in serodiscordant couples wishing to have children. AIDS 14,2093–2099.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Quayle AJ, Xu C, Tucker L and Anderson DJ (1998) The case against an association between HIV-1 and sperm: molecular evidence. J Reprod Immunol 41,127–136.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Semprini AE, Levi-Setti P, Bozzo M, Ravizza M, Taglioretti A, Sulpizio P, Albani E, Oneta M and Pardi G (1992) Insemination of HIV-negative women with processed semen of HIV-positive partners. Lancet 340,1317–1319.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Semprini AE, Levi-Setti P, Ravizza M and Pardi G (1998) Assisted conception to reduce the risk of male-to-female sexual transfer of HIV in serodiscordant couples: an update [abstract]. Symposium on AIDS in Women, Sao Paulo, Brazil.
CiteULike 
Connotea 
Del.icio.us What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
 |
|
  L. Bujan, M. Daudin, N. Moinard, P. Plante, J. Parinaud, and C. Pasquier Azoospermic HIV-1 infected patients wishing to have children: proposed strategy to reduce HIV-1 transmission risk during sperm retrieval and intracytoplasmic sperm injection: Case Report Hum. Reprod., September 1, 2007; 22(9): 2377 - 2381. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 E. van Leeuwen, J.M. Prins, S. Jurriaans, K. Boer, P. Reiss, S. Repping, and F. van der Veen Reproduction and fertility in human immunodeficiency virus type-1 infection Hum. Reprod. Update, March 1, 2007; 13(2): 197 - 206. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
|
|
|
|
|
|
V. Savasi, E. Ferrazzi, C. Lanzani, M. Oneta, B. Parrilla, and T. Persico Safety of sperm washing and ART outcome in 741 HIV-1-serodiscordant couples Hum. Reprod., March 1, 2007; 22(3): 772 - 777. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||